Where each item comes from
Eyeballs are a farm crop: plant an Eyeleaf Seed, sold by Old Man Crawford, and allow four days for it to grow. The game also lists eyeballs among its useful crops.
Wormsprout Seed grows Worm in four days and is also sold by Old Man Crawford. Bitter Herb is a forage found in Town, Town Outskirts, the Mall, and the Old Woods; it restores 2 HP and is a cooking ingredient, with item data also listing crafting use.
Cursed Milk is the ink-black, toxic-scented milk obtained by milking the Tentacow imposter when it appears on the Ranch.
What to do with the materials
- What is Worm used for?
- Worm is fishing bait harvested from Wormsprout. It is also listed as loot from Tier 1 Bait Packs and a sleep event, with other sources including garbage loot and Sam at the Lakefront.
- How are Eyeballs and Bitter Herb classified in the gift list?
- Pickled Eyeballs is in the Universal Loved Gifts list; Bitter Herb is in the Universal Hated Gifts list. Bitter Herb also has its documented forage, HP-restoration, cooking and crafting roles.
- Where does Cursed Milk come from?
- Milk the Tentacow imposter when it appears on the Ranch.